日本の技術者制度変革の停滞と混乱 ～その問題分析と
Contents
1.2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14. 2
15. 2 3
16. ABETLEC2000 d Function on multi disciplinary teams JABERE Q 2012 G
17. 4 39 Schon
18. 1 2
19. 3 lt 4 TT E 02 10
20. 112
21. 34 3 APEC 34 1 4 3
22. 28 JABEE 2000 2
23. 102 1 2 2 1 5 2 1 2 1 3 2 1 1
24. I lt 19 ya 1997 2009b 87
25. Design
26. 1 2 3 JABEE 116 50 50 2014
27. 68 1 interactivelly pp 41 2 Schon
28. 133 The Accreditation Board for Engineering and Technology
29. 14 2013 11 19 ABET EC2000
30. Schon reflective conversation
31. E 8 1 2 3 1 2 i E 1 2 OO
32. _
33. 4 200
34. J 122 2 JABEE
35. a b c d e g h Hh 1
36. 3 1 1 8
37. 5 6 107
38. 143 T 1
39. 1 2 11 8 1991 3 1995 1 2 APEC
40. 1998b 2 45 3 1 5 3 ABETLEC2000 JABEE ABRTLEC2000 g Communicate effectively JABEE c ABRTLEC2000
41. 1938 13 ABET Code of Echics Guideline Code of Echics 1961 36
42. 4 LT 134
43. GA Graduate Attributes PC Professional Competencies 3 GA PC 1
44. 3 _
45. 1990 8 9 8 3
46. 1 1 2011 EE ul a
47. professional knowledge Schon Schon
48. 1 1 3 2 3 E 1998 1999 8
49. Qr 46 JABEE HH JABEE 10
50. 5
51. 1 2 9 JABEE 4 engineering design
52. 5 IV H 1
53. 4 1
54. 1 4 8 1999 8 1
55. Millerson1964 1 OR EF
56. 1995 E E 1950 4 1979 1986 H
57. 2009 iv 1
58. Design
59. desired needs desired needs reflective conversation
60. 2 1 1 2 18 37 5 2014 1 9 1 2007 1 2011 1 2014 1 2014 2 2007 13 1 2008 5 2003 05 07 09 14 1 2010
61. 20 2
62. ABET ABET Coge of Ethics Guidline 6 3 1 1 1 1997 6
63. CN VID 1985 2
64. E FE reframe 1 1
65. gt E 7
66. 3 professional profession professionalization professional profession 128 professionalization professionalizati
67. E a
68. a 9 e
69. 3 3 APEC APEC 3
70. The Accreditation Board for Engineering and Technology
71. E 3 profession professionalhization occupation profession 76
72. 1 5 1 JABEE APEC CPD E on 1 1 2 3 2
73. 1883 8 1979 280 1886 3 3 Dyer 7
74. Design Analysis Synthesis
75. 4 Y 82
76. 4 3
77. 2 K
78. 2 1 1 3 1 1 2 6 1 4
79. 4 desired needs desire 5 iterative and often open ended often iterative
80. 1 2 55 1 5 1 1 4 2 f
81. 1977 1996 11 gt
82. JABEE ABET EC2000 ABETLEC2000 103 x
83. 58 4 3 3 4 2 1 APEC
84. _ Ft 3
85. I 1 2 1 1995 11
86. 2
87. 1 2 E 8
88. E
89. 4 7 lt 3 JABEE 2 2
90. 1 2 1 1 104 3 8
91. LF ua 9
92. 3 JABEE JABEE
93. 3 2 Engineering Profession 2 1 1 8 2 PE 2 Engineering Profession Graduate Attributes GA and Protessional Competency Profiles PO TEA2009 2013 2 2
94. 1 2 1 1 2 2 111 2 1 1 2 3 3
95. PC Professional Competency GA Graduate Attributes PC 1 2 8 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 GA 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12
96. 2018b 1 2 10 1 2 7 1H 1 n 3 H E 44
97. kk 2 3 PE 2 Engineering Professsional 40 TIEA2009 IEAGA amp PC 2012 72
98. 2 3 3 Schon reflective conversation
99. 1979 392 10 2 gt 4 2014 Engineering 3
100. oO EE 3 i
101. 8 2 3 1933 1936 96 R 2014 1913 ed p 21S 1910 ed p 708 1927 ed p 216 1927 English ed p 1356 1978 ed p 630 2005 cd p 1043 3 2 2 Engineering 2014 0 2 5 kgKB Fe kcal kp K ee 12 41 E Schmidt Technische Thermodynamik ct a Grundlagen unde Anwendungen 11 auflage K Stephan F Mayinger 2 5 1950 SbnBer 1936 Einfuhrung in die technische 0 Thermodynamik 83 2 3 1985
102. B 47 4 1 1 2012a 106 2009 33 ACN E 4 1 1
103. JABEE 2 3 3 JABEE 3 1 1
104. O
105. 1991 2000 JABEE JABEE 124 JABEE
106. E fH 4 E E 1997 1998
107. JABEE JABEE 500 r 240 000 200 000 400 160 000 A 120 000 200 80000 40 000 lt oo L232 4 1 a ea a M 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 1 2 1 JABEE 18 1 2 1 2001 2013 19 54 220 10 24 54 150 50 79 1 1 169 474 18
108. desired needs 2 2 iterative iterative and often open ended often iterative terative 90
109. just in time
110. 113 1 input output _2 1 2 3 4 _ 5 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 4 2 1 1 1
111. 1998b 1998b 1999a b 3 2 23 1 5
112. 1979 274 Dyer 1879 ul 1 1881 1880 Dyer 1882 1979 800 1
113. 2 3
114. APEC ul APEC H
115. 1 131 3 ke 1 NOG
116. 5 TV 1990 IV H Qr
117. 49 2005 v 21 2007 1 Eg 2 2005a b
118. 3 2 79 SOCE 2 APEC 2 1 ar a H gt 1
119. aaa 3 2000 f kL ss f 3 1 E 3 1991 1
120. 78 3 4
121. 2002b 49 1996 7 14 1997 7 1999 1 1998
122. 2007 V 5 26 2008 1 61 2013 De 27 a IEA International Engineering Alliance 2009 Graduate Attributes GA and Proftessional Competency Profiles PCO 2 TEA2009 IEAGA amp PC 2012 Multi disciplinary team diversified team
123. GA PC GA 2 3 GA GA
124. PE 14 2000 6 2 APEC
125. 1 1989 HSB 1880 HSB HSB J M Allen ASME 1 1911 1914 Pressure Vessel Code hy E ASME 4SME Boiler gz HSB 1915 1920 64
126. 2 JABEE 2008 12 2 JABER JABEE 2009ajb 2009ajb
127. 2
128. 3 2 1 1 2 9
129. 2 GA 2 1 GA GA GA GA 2 2 GA
130. 1 1 PE 11 2 1995 FE Fundamental Engineer PE Professional Engineer PE 2001 23 8 a me APEC 5 16 APEC 2009
131. 2 3 1 JABEE i 57 8 4 1 2 3 JABEE 4
132. LFM Technology and Policy Program 18 200
133. i CSR 3 e
134. A Study of the Impact of EC2000 ABETEC2000 1980 b ABET 125 EC2000 1997 4 70
135. reading writing hearing speaking 4 2 2 Communication skill
136. 1 NE 1 1
137. 4 2 1 2 2 4 1 1 1 1991 VID Rngineering Council 1 2 1 1 JABRE
138. 2011 3 1 1 8 1 2 1 2 2 1 2 3 9
139. 1 g1 Gm1 m2 G1 21 11 g2 G3 31 m5 G4 4 1 31 G2 2 21 41 g3 G3 31 0 m3 7 m6 8 g5 G6
140. 8 1 3 CPD 4 1 2 E 3
141. IEA rr 125 127
142. profession b profession profession 75
143. professional 73 1 2 1 professional professional professionalization 2 1 1 4 Geoffrey Millerson professionalhization 1 profession
144. 100 4 1 3 4 1 3 4 4 2 2 10
145. 18 5 Professional Engineer 1989 6 2000 5 6 Pa 2
146. 2 f 2 3 4
147. 4 2007 CE 6 2 3 CPD 32
148. APEC PE 6 1 1 2 1960 80 1 ABETEC2000 38 RCPD Canons of Ethics for Engineers 66 1960 80 EC2000
149. 2010 1 2 1991 O 2 1 47 3 1
150. 0 393 MC 43 1 2 8 JABEE
151. 2010 1 1 2
152. E SO 2000 2 2000 2001 23 4 2001 CPD
153. 3 3 3 3 f 3 4 4 3 4 Dc 59 2 3 1 8 1 1 3 CS 61 62 a EC 63 1 1 1 PE 1 2 3 PE 3 1 1 2 1960
154. 1999 2002 CPD 1 2 1 mw APEC Asia Pacific Economic Cooperation Japan Acceditation Board for Engineering Education JABEE JABRE 2000 PDE 1
155. E 102 103 1 1 1 2 1 2 1 1 2 2 1 2 3 3 4 5
156. APEC 22 APEC ROSS 14 23 TIEA2013 2018 6 17 21 http Nev engineer or jp c_cmt kokusai topics 002 002765 html 2014 10 15 24 2 APEC RU NN IN 6 http www engineer or jp c_topics70007000159 html 36
157. 1 1 4 1 2 1997 1 1 1 c 1 1 2 16 1 4 1 2 1997 1 1 1 a 17 1998 Harris et al 1995 2000 Gunn A and Vesilind P 1998 NSPE1999 Whitbeck C 1998 2002 Martin M and SchinzingerR 2000
158. 49 2018 109
159. 1 1995 JABEE 1995 3 1995 7 0 JABEE 1 APEC
160. 1 5 1 3 1 2 3 APEC 8 1 JABEE APEC 1 1 1 1991 1995 E JABEE
161. 2004 JABEE 2012 3 0 8 25 JABEE 2004
162. CPD 1 Es 2 CPD 3 4 5 ECE E
163. 3 2000 APEC 2 1 APEC APEC JABEE H gn i
164. 2 1 1 3 3
165. 1997 81 JABEE 1 3 3 3
166. 1938 1961 1996 17 1998 7 1999 i i 2000 i 2001 i 2002 i 2003 i 2011 1999 JABEE 1 5 8 2001 2001 2002 2003 2004 2004
167. 4 1991 9 E 1 1 1 Engineering 1 2
168. E 2009 Nl CPD 4 GL FE 50 CPD ECE ECE Bmngineering Capacity Enhancement Program CPD
169. JABEE 3
170. 10 2013 10 12 E APEC APEC 2
171. JABEE 3 CE PB CE
172. 1992 3 APEC 8 So APEC 3 3 1995 11 APEC CPD Continuous Professional Development accreditation CPD
173. 5 2 1 1 APRC 5 1 1
174. PED 2002 26 IntPE APEC Engineer register EN CPD CPD os 5 CPD J CPD 2012
175. 8 1998b 1999b c 2 1 1 8 IEC2009 PC 13 GA 12 PC 1 2 3 4
176. 29 JABEE 2012 12 48 JABEE JABEE 30 JABEE 2012
177. 110
178. 1 2 T 1 1 1 1 3 1 1991 1991 3 1 2 APEC 1 2 APEC 3 3 APEC 1 8 1 1 4 1 4 1 2 1997
179. MN 139 2 1998b 4 5
180. 114 4 5 1 input output
181. E 2 R 2 1995 235 6 professionalization
182. 1 2 2 engineering profession 1 professional 3 1 2
183. 1 2 1998 3 3 3 3
184. E 2005 203 STS Seience STS E STS 3 Bay Are a Rapid Transit District BART IEEE
185. 19 1 2 3 33 3 CPD CPD 1 5 1 3 CPD 1 2 2 20 2000 2002 2004 2006 2008 2010 2012 CPD CPD Du
186. Schon problem setting i 123 E k
187. 1 2 2 2 1 4 2 1 3 1 1 8 1 1
188. F Schon reflective conversation 3
189. 1 4 1 52 2 KO 3 f AU2 8 2003 3 2 2003
190. 1998 2002a 52 1 1991 1997
191. 5 1 88 ABETLTEC2000 g Communicate effectively JABEE 1 ABETLTEC2000 i Recognize the need for and
192. 1 1 1 1991 1991 E ABETEC2000 1996 4
193. 2006 gt PS 3 a a 8TS 2
194. 3 APEC APEC
195. 8 3 4 1 120 1 2 1 2 2 1 2
196. 8 80 8 2 9 80 8
197. 8 4 NOY 5 60 LT IL 1 1 8 APEC 3 2 APBC
198. JABEE JABEE 2012 0
199. Technoliteracy 3 5 2
200. 1 1 4 1 1997 2 gt 2 1999 6 5 2004 1997 RE 1 8 APEC
201. 987 PE NCEES National Council of Examiners for Engineering and Surveying 1920 PE 4 ECPD Engineer s Council for Professional Development 1980 4 2 ECPD 1932 PE 37 PE PR PE
202. 13 95 5 1926
203. RM E 1 JABEE 1999 1 rt E JABEE
204. 4 H 1998a 90 2 ul 2
205. 1995 2009 1 2009 IEA 3 Engineering Profession Professional Engineer Engineering Technologist Engineering Technician Professional Engineer Engineering Technologist Engineering Technician 2009 Engineering Technician Professional Engineer 3 Engineering Profession Engineering Profession Professional Engineer PE Professional Engineer
206. 1EA2009 PC GA ABET IRA APEC 1 1 1 2 professional APEC PE Professional Engineer professionalization professional occupation profession
207. 8 Engineering Profession 129 CPD gt JABEE JABEE CPD JABEE 4
208. EC Accreditation
209. NN TO 990 intern MIT Leader for Manufacturing 5 0
210. 1 2 2 3
211. 16 1996 1996 1997 IFTP International Federation for Information Processing 90 1998 2003 17 1997 2009 y 28 1 1 2
212. 2012 2012 JABEE 41 2013a 12 13 JABEE JABEE
213. ABET EC2000 e Identify formulate and solve engineering problems f Understand professional and ethical responsibility h Understand the impact of engineering solutions in a global and societal context j Have knowledge of contemporary issues JABEE 1 2 3
214. 1 12 ASME 2 i 2006 PE 1907 PE 1947
215. 3 2 JABEE 4 4 2004 2009a
216. 1 2 7 desired needs 1 2 3 desired needs desired needs
217. 8 5 90
218. 3 115 4 5 6 7
219. 2 1 1 3 2 3 1 1 2 3 ABETLRC2000 2 1 3 8 APEC 4 3 2 1
220. CS OR 2 R 77 1 1 1 1 1 2
221. ji ABETLEC2000 1 1 2 H 8 4 JABERE 1 2 2 3 APEC 1 CPD
222. 1 138 1993 outcomes SE KRB PBP
223. H 1 EE 1997 3 H gt 1 1 5 2 1 1 2 2 1
224. 2012 Multi disciplinary team diversified team G 27 2018 JABEE 25 3 2006 3 JABEE ES SA
225. 1 2 3
226. 2010 24 1 5 3 JABEE 1 4 8 JABEE 29 1 5 1 1999 JABERE JABER ABET Engineering Criteria2000 ABETLREC2000 ABE
227. NSR 26 JABEE 2004 12 2009a JABEE 2009b LU
228. 3 JABEE 1 2 2 JABEE 8 1 2 3 5 1 3 1
229. professionalization 8 1 2 2 4 2 3 sa
230. 1 1 1991 14 3 5 1991 1991 3 1 1991 1991
231. 18 1995 E 2 1997 f WFEO 1997 4 1995 ER E 6 3 i
232. B 2 H f Ne 2 2 HH 2 E
233. 1 1 1 2 2 1 2 8 4 1 1 8 1 2 3 1 2 PE Q 7 1 8 1 1 2 ABETFEC2000 1997
234. _ APEC EU NAFTA 137 10 8 1 1 998a
235. 2 Schon artistry 4
236. 2014 E 10 15 0 2000 2002 2004 2006 2008 2010 2012 2014 2016 1 2 3 APRC 20 2 2 1 1 5 2 1
237. ABET the Accreditation Board for REngineering and ABET 10 JABEE EK 17 1 4
238. ml H 2 4 2 5 GA 3 PC 3 1 PC
239. 2 H 2014 59 72 APRC 2005 2 500 H 1 se f
240. 2009a 2009b 1 2009b JABEE JABRE http www jabee org7news_archive news2009 20090318 2 2356 2014 3 1 2005 9 203 18 2 2014 ET 9 71 83 2005 vol 17 No 1 p 38 2011 2011 2003 2003
241. 30 2012 JABEE I 31 SR A 2005 Nh 2007 2009 IV 2012
242. JABEE JABEE 1 1999 a E 1 c d T
243. 1 3 4 1 3 4 4 1
244. 10 1 mw 6 H Engineering Council EC 9 5 N
245. PE 1991 1 1 3 APEC 1 3 APEC 3 APRC APEC 2
246. EC2000 http wwwr abet org History 2014 11 30 ABET ABETEC2000 71 IEA ABETEC2000 ABET 1989 PE 1997 IPEA International Professional Engineers Agreement PE 2000 APRC PE 2 Engineering Profession Engineering Technologist Engineering Technician IEA International Engineering Alliance
247. JABEE EE engineering science skill for engineering practice 3 2 130 14 5 3 3 25 1991
248. 1 1 1 1947 4 ABETTEC2000 1 Schon 1 Donald A Schon MIT
249. 1 1 1 PE PE Carl Mitcham Mitcham C2001 2005 1 1824 Rensselaer Polytechnic School 1860 1867
250. 92 2 2 1 3 1 8
251. 4 1 2 3 JABEE JABEE 1 2012 99 ara 3
252. ET 153
253. VDI Rngineering Counail Peer Review 9 6 20 1997
254. cl E mm S
255. 4 iterative and often open ended often iterative 5 2 1 desired needs ABETEC2000 desired needs 1 2 38 desire 89 desired needs
256. Earnest Greenwood1957 Geoffrey Millerson1964 NE Greenwood 2005 Millerson 2004 2009a 2007 2004 2012 b 1 Greenwood1957 2005 g1 g2 g3 g4 g5 b 2 Millerson1964 2007 m1 m2 m3 m4 m5
257. 1 2 1 1 2 2 2 105 v 3 9 1 2 3 8 1 2
258. GATS 1991 12 1989 8 Counail of Examiners for Si and Surveying Engineer9 NCEES A 1992 1993 1 Organizations APEC
259. 2 4 4 LU 1 2 140
260. 2004 21 1 a 8 EE 1991 1997
261. Ef 1 E CPD r IPD Initial Professional Development E 3 HE E engineering education
262. JABEE PDE Continuing Professional Development CPD professional engineer CPD 1 1 2 2001 TP Accord TE MINHNL 1 1 2 2001 6 APEC
263. The Reflective Practitioner How Protessionals Think in Action Schon1983 Reflective Practition MG ul 1963 1981 Schon Reflective Practition Schen1983 2007 89 Schen
264. 21 2 CPD 1 1 2 2 3 APEC 4 CPD 20 2014 72 21
265. 3 4 E F E
266. ABET IEA 3 121 1 4 2
267. ABET EC2000 JABEE 54 JABERE 1 4 3 1991 Fm 8 ee E 5 2 1 4 2 1998
268. 2 1 5 2 2011 211 187 21 3 56 5 4 3 4 2 8 1 40 58 1 2 3 1 2 4
269. 83 3 2 2 84 1 ABET EC2000 Schon 2 1 1 2 1 ABETLEC2000 2 1 1 2 3 1 2 3 IEA 2 1 1 3
270. artistry Schon2007 p 1 problem solving problem setting
271. 1 1995 1 1 APEC 1995 E 3 1 2 1995 APEC 1 8 E 1 4 APRC 8 1 5 rp 3
272. _ Center of Excellence O 132
273. Qr F 3 11 3 3 JABEE 1 2 SOE 1
274. g 2 2000 2011 c g hb 6 141 G
275. 8 6 Center of Excellence 3 1
276. 8 1998 11 http www eng hokudai ac jp jeep 08 10 pdfH9Hokoku pdf 2013 10 26 1999a 8 8 1999 1 18 http www eng hokudai ac p jeep 08 10 pdf pamph03 pdf 2013 10 26 1999b 10 8 8 1999 8 http www eng hokudai ac jp jeep 08 10 pdf 10hokoku pdf 2013 10 26 200472012 Lattuca R L Terenzini T P Volwein F J 2006a Engineering Change A Study of the Impact of EC2000 Executive Summary ABET http wwwr abet org engine
277. 1 2 2 8 1 1 2 33 1
278. 3 2012 a b c 9 e g hb ABET EC2000 ABETLEC2000 Engineering Criteria 2000 Lattuca et al 2006b
279. E JABEE CPD CPD APEC 1 JABEE JABEE JABEE JABEE 2001 15 11 15 2005 2012 82 11 1 2 1 1 2 1 JABERE 2005 95 2009
280. No 6 2010 1 2 8 2 I 3 IV 1 2 2 3 APEC
281. 8 1 2 2 r 3 2
282. 3 1997 49 Coge of ZZ77cg x 1 1 1 O
283. lt Qr LT OO SSM 1 LC gt professionalization W Millerson
284. 25 PDE 1999 Hy E CPD 12 CPD 2013 APEC Engineer CPD PED 2000 CPD CPD 2001 PDE CPD 2002 PDE 2005 2006
285. 1 1 Schon fi 91
286. 20 8 2 1 3 2 2 Engineering Engineering 3 2 3 8 PA Engineering 4 1940 232 46
287. 2007 vol 19 No 2 28 29 2001 2001 JABEE 2002 2002 3 JABEE 2003 2004 7 JABEE 2007 2006 wwwjjabee org public_doc download docid 333 2013 10 10 2008 2008 JABEE 2009 2009 JABEE 2010 JABEE 2004 11 JABEE 3 mo 13 1999 2012 JABEE 2012 JABEE http www jabee org OpenHomePage accreditation_o 2012_k htm kijun 2013 10 10 RY JABEE _121225 pdf 2018 10 27 2003
288. E Understand professional and ethical responsibility ABET EC2000 Lattuca et al 2006 1 ABET ABETEC2000 ABETEC2000 JABEE 2 RD 1 1 3 ABET
289. OE JABEE NNN JABEE 3 4 4 CPD
290. 1873 Engineering J 2 4 JABEE 2 E 9 NT 2 2014 2
291. 2 E 2006 2010 8 STS
292. APEC APEC 3 1 4 1 APEC 1 1 3
293. A 4 IN 2011 2012 1 BE
294. 1998 E
295. 2010 http www mext go jp b_menvwshingi chousa koutou 41 index htm 2013 10 26 2000 http www mext go jp b_menvu shingi old_gijyutu gjyutushi_index toushin 1818776 htm 2013 11 12 1995 2006 Vo1 54 1 28 31 2003 2008 2006 2009 2012 2012 20038 NTT
296. 4 3 ABETEC2000 Lattuca et al 2006a ABETTEC2000 Lattuca et al 2006a EE ss 1994 1992 STS Martin M and
297. 2012 i E WFEO The World Federation of Engineering NCEES National Professional 2001 189 APEC 8 8 2014 9 4
298. 2004 2 4 jpp 74 77 2005 IT 2 47 64 2012 2 3 pp 66 84 gs 2003 No 2 pp 138 148 2003 i 2008 2008 2009 JABEE JABEE3 JABEE http 7 www jabee org about_jabee message 200906 2 2013 10 4
299. 3 2 1 E 2
300. 1991 1991
301. 2 IN 2 I 1 1874
302. ABETLEngineering Accreditation Commission 2015 2016 Criteria tor Accreditating Engineering Programs http wwwr abet org eac criteria 2015 2016 2014 12 5 a Apply knowledge of mathematics science and engineering an ability to apply knowledge of mathematics science and engineering b Design and conduct experiments analyze and interpret data an ability to design and conduct experiments as well as to analyze and interpret data c Design a system component or process to meet desired needs an ability to design a system component or process to meet desired needs within realistic constraints such as economic environmental social political ethical health and safety manufacturability and sustainability d Function on multi disciplinary teams an ability to function on multi disciplinary teams e Identify formulate and solve engineering problems an ability to identify formulate and solve engineering problems f Understand professional and ethical responsibility an understanding of professional and ethical responsibility g Communicate effectively an ability to communicate effectively h Understand the impact of engineering solutions in a global and societal context the broad education necessary to understand the impact of engineering solutions in a global economic environmental and societa
303. 2003 2003 2003 2008 2009 2006 2008 2010 0 2008 2012 2008 2006 2006 2011 2011
304. 6 2 2 1 1 wy SS 2 gt 2 2 1 3 4 2 3 gt gt Pe 1 2
305. 2 8 1 3 4 4 1 1 3 1 2 PE ABETEC2000
306. 1991 1995 APEC 1 1 3 APEC APEC 1
307. 48 2012a c 108 4 1 1
308. 1
309. 1 H 1 80 3 CPD S Ls 2 3 8 E 3 APEC
310. N J mK 20 APEC 2 APEC 1997 DD
311. 2000 6 1 ME 0 MO 2 6 JABEE gt 1 0 1 lt 000 5 6 3 2000 6 A 1 3 APEC 3
312. CPD 815 2013 CPD 10 8 CPD 2014 CPD CPD 2013 CPD CPD1 APEC 1995 APEC Employabihity E CPD CPD CPD
313. i APEC H 2000 APEC 2018 F 15 JABEE 1 PDE
314. 2 2 CPD IPD Imtial Professional Development CPD 2012 il 1 5 2 1 4 1 1997 1997 2
315. 7 1997 1997 JABEE 1999 1996 1999 APEC 2002 JABEE 2 2005 APEC JABEE
316. 26 4 236 237 2014c E 77 78 2014 I IEA International Engineering Alliance 2009 Graduate Attributes and Professional Competencies ver 2 JABEE http www jabee org international_relations ea 2013 10 26 IEAGA amp PC 2012 IEAGraduate Attributes and Professional Competencies 22 23 pp 265 282 http hneng ta chiba u jp 8080 2013 10 26 2006 2006
317. 1998a 1998b a
318. 2011 1 Vol 59 4 119 122 2012 Vol 60 1 119 123 1998a 8 8 1998 5 147 8 http www eng hokudai ac jp jeep 08 10 pdfpamph01 pdf 2013 10 26 1998b 8 8 1998 9 17 http www eng hokudai ac jp jeep 08 10 pdf7pamph02 pdf 2013 10 26 1998c 9
319. 2012 1 E 2 3 JABEE JABEE E 2 11 SE 2013 oe
320. 4 JABEE A E jabee 2014 12 23 2005 b CPDI 2013 lt 1 8 13 2007 2009
321. 1979 94 BE AN E 1979 lmperial College of 2 Zt Ld 18 College Principal Henry Dyer 1 Dyer
322. 3 1 1 3 1 1 2 1
323. 8 1 2 APEC 2 62 1 3 APEC
324. Vol1 017 http www nttcom co p comzine archive talk talk04 index htm1l 2013 10 8 1991 14 5 http wwwrsj go jp ja info kohyo 12 14 21 pdf 2013 10 10 1997 http www sj go jp ja info kohyo 16youshr16_55h html 2013 10 8 2001 50 2006 2008 2004 21 URL http www engineer or jp c_topics 000 000081 html 2013 2 28 2005a 21
325. profession 2 1 2 Millerson profession 6 Millerson 1964 9 5 co
326. 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 GA 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 PE ABETEC2000
327. JABEE sr 5 1 2 3 1 2 2
328. 1 1 3 1 2 1 1 3 3 3 1 1 1 1 1 2 1 1 3
329. 3 2 PC PC 3 18 2 3 GA 144 3 3 PC GA PC Dh PC
330. APEC 1 1 3 APEC 1 1 2 2 1 E APEC Q 3 1 2 2 1 4 1 3 1 E APEC 1
331. ER or Competency of Abilities to Abilities to build Engineering Analise Problems and Engineering Moethoda Design Evaluate Methods Internal Rationality Refrective External Rationality conversation Communication Skill Ability to accomplish duties premeditatedly alone and in team 3 1 1 85 Engineering Autonomy 1 Recognize the need for and engage im lifelong learning Abilities to build ems Engineering Methods and Evaluate Methods Internal Rationality External Rationality a Apply knowledge of mathematics science and engineering b Design and conduct e Identify formulate and solve engineering problems f Understand professional and c Design a ethical responsibility experiments analyze syStem h Understand the impact of and interpret data component or engineering solutions in k Use modern process to meet a global and societal context engineering tools desiredneeds 1 Have knowledge of necessary for contemporary issues _ Communication Skil g Communicate effectively _eng
332. JABERE 2010 6
333. RD A Cs 4 1970 2 1971 1970 Technology and Society 4 4 1970 E E 2 2006 1970
334. desired need 1 2 3
335. 2 1 1 2005 203 4 2 2008 230 2 10 000 1865 1 238
336. 2009 2014 10 16 pdf 2014 10 16 2013b 2012 http www jabee org OpenHomePage kijun 2013kaisetsu_Eng 2014 2014 outline documents 2014 CPD ECE 2014 http wwwjfes orjp _cpd doc ece program guideline_20140508 A je 12 H E 150 2009 ECE http www jabee org lt 2003 CPD 2018 CPD http wwwrjfes orJjp cpd about index html 2013 10 8 CPD ECE 2018 ECE http wwwijfes or jp _cpd doc e
337. 2014 15 2014 32 1 2 2 8 JABEE 2014 4 RE IIUNNRNIIMNMM 0 0 0 MM 4 15 0 2 5 25 2 7 16 16 0 0 16 17 1 1 5 13 1 2 6 21 0 0 5 16 1 3 6 15 0 0 3 63 138 5 15 8 11 1 JABEE 2 JABEE JABEE JADMM JABEE http www jabee SNBBGCP6HHHSEIBH7DRODRan0 3 1
338. 3 4 3 5 4 4 1 4 2 5 5 1 5 2 Graduate Attribute 6 Professional Competency 145 yh 2009b 2010 2003 J 2004 2009a Vo1 4 85 96 Vol 7 pp 23 71
339. 1 1999 1 CPD 1 2 1 3 CPD JABEE JABEE CE PE JABEE 2011 3 PE 1 1 2
340. 2 2
341. 2 1 1993 Engineering Ethics 2009b
342. 5 EE ERBX 1 4 3 1996 E 9 3 22 1991 1997 E 8 1998a b c 1999a b 1990
343. 34 CPD http www jsme or jp cpd setumei htm 2014 10 15 3 CPD 1 2 3 Employability CPD H APEC 1 CPD1 CPD 2014 CPD 2 095 CPD 8 660
344. 0 1870 1880 1890 1900 1910 1920 1930 1940 15 1 2 1 1 20 30 2005 208 5 1 4 PE 3 PE 3 20 PE Professional Rngineer 2 1 1 2
345. 65 ABET ECPD NSPE National NSPE 1945 PE 1934 Society of Professional Rngineers E ECPD ECPD 1946 38 NSPE 2 8 ABET ECPD and Electronics Engineers
346. 3 3 1 1 4 1 1 1 5 2
347. 1 1 APEC 2 3 2 3 JABEE
348. 2010 53 1 E 2 H ber
349. 3 JABEE 1 3 3 3 JABERE
350. 3 8 59 2 3 3 2 3 4
351. GATT General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade 1986 1991 1994 4 GATT WTO World Trade Organization 4 1 GATS General Agreement on Trade in Services 1 WTO
352. 92 12 88 Z RS 13 14 15 16 17 181 2 Av 3 4 79 74 57 55 54 1 80 19 221 I23 27 53 19 53 21 38 36 4 E 39 0 v
353. B EB 1 5 2 1 1 4 2 APEC 1998 12
354. 2 3 2 DD DD TV QO J 1 3 professional profession E HE ln 112 119 120 121 123 Engineering Profession 127 128 professionalization 4 Professional Engineer CPD 2
355. 3 3 4 61 2 3 3 1 APEC 1 1
356. 43 93 1 3 3 2 1 JABEE 2 2
357. 69 2006 20 1970 2003 138 1985 ABET 1 Schinzinger R 2000 1 5 2 2006 22 1 1 1 3 STS
358. input output 2 3 1 2
359. 1 5 2 38 1 2 3 2011 J E FF FE H II0 TE M CSR
360. 2013 Vol 60 45 50 02 26 216 217 2014a JABEE 60 2011 2012a 2018 5 Vol 6 15 34 146 UL 2014b
361. 3 APEC JABEE 5 2 2 Q k 3 3 2 11 3 1 ABET EC2000 1 1 PE ABET EC2000 1 3 4 5 6
362. 2 8 1 ECE 4 Rmployability 2 3 f 4
363. 2002 2 1 2 1 gt JABEE PDE CPD 1995 JABEE 3
364. 2014 2000 1 2 2 2000 44 840 2013 80 211 OCR PR 19 10 2 4 JABEE PE
365. Canon 8 4 3 E 4 10 12 17 136 gt
366. E Schon1983 2007 Schon
367. Schen reflective reflective conversation Schon Schon 2007 148 151 reframe f
368. 1 2011 2011 3 11
369. EC2000 JABER E 35 ABET JABEE 35 JABEE 56 3
370. 3 1852 ASCE The American Society of Civil Engineers 1880 ASME The American Society of Mechanical Engineers 1884 36 1776 1783 63 AIEE American Institute of Electrical Engineers 19 1 lt 6 1850 1910
371. CPD ECE 4 3 2 2 1 3 3 1
372. ECE 21 3 CPD ECE 22 24 23 33 CPD ECE 2013 2014 51 ECE E ECE INIMS 25 ECE
373. PE 2004 6 21 2004 21 9 ASH ee
374. PE 5 8 E 2 1 2
375. 2 9 3 APEC 3 3 3 3 3 2 2 APEC 3
376. 3 10 4 3 1 1 JABEE
377. ECUK E IEET 2311 ABRET 1930 JABEE 450 10 JABEE ABEEK JABEE 8 1 JABEE ul 1 1 2 2 31
378. N su i dk E gt NN 1 2 4 1 23 2011 394 2 347 38 299 4 192 5 176 6 142 7 140 101 al 101 I10 93 11
379. 1 JABEE 28 2 1 2 9 3 1 2 8 1 2 9
380. 1 1 APEC 1 2 3 1 APEC 3 3 8
381. 20 4 E 1997 12 2006 2010 13 2002a 52 2002b 49 2000 23 1997 1997
382. 2002 2009 2013 2010 ET Greenwood E 1957 Ernest basic attributes of protfessions http www richardcheeks com professor profat tributes x htm Greenwood In the July 1957 issue of Social Work Cited five 2014 12 5 Gunn A and Vesilind P 1998 Engineering Ethics and the Environment Cambridge University Press 2000 Harris C Pritchard M and Rabins M 1995 2000 2005 Engineering Ethics Concepts and Cgses Wadsworth R ul 1998 2002 2008 Nl r Vol 9 51 77 2012b 2012c
383. J EE 1 ABET 1 1 3 RN ABET E 1998 ABET ABET 1980 ECPD 1979 1989 ABET 2 ABET 680 3300 12 05 ABRT
384. TEA 2 Engineering Profession PE 2 Bmngineering Profession 2000 APEC PE 1 8 1 APEC JABEE
385. 3 4 2 2 1 3 JABEE 3 3 4 JABEE
386. 98 H a 2 1 1
387. JABEE 5 1 3 4 4 1 2 4 3 7Y 2 2 1 8 4 1 APEC 1
388. http www jabee org about_ E 2012 1 3 1 32 CPD CPD 2 1 2 8 1 2
389. 1 2 14 5 ee ee 131 1991 1997 8 JABERE 1998 10 998a 998b ABETEC2000 IEA Graduate Attributes and Protessional Competencies ver 2 2009 IE
390. 7 2 1 desired needs 2 terative 2 85 93 2 1 1 2 3 4 2 2 1 4 1
391. 2 B Technology 30 H 6 4 60 3 SE
392. JABERE 1 JABERE 29 JABEE JABEE 2012 JABEE JABEE JABEE JABREE JABEE JABEE 2
393. PE PE PE NSPE IEEE Institute of Electrical 2005 203 5 1991 1 E APEC 3 5 1 1 2
394. Schon A Donald1983 The Reflective Practitioner Basic Books 2007 2001 2005 2013 2008 Fundamentals Review Vol 2 No 3 pp 4 18 2006 2006 2009 vol 21 No 1 3 2007 vol 19 No 1 p 3 2012 vol1 24 No 1p 8 Uy 2001 2003 2005 2008 Whitbeck C 1998 Ethics in Engineering Practice and Research
395. 1 4 2 1 4 3 1 5 1 5 1 1 JABEE 2 CPD 3 1 5 2 1 2 1 5 8 JABEE 2 31 2 1 1 JABEE 2
396. 2011 2012b 2014b c 86 ABETLTEC2000 a Apply knowledge of mathematics science and engineering b Design and conduct experiments analyze and interpret data k Use modern engineering tools necessary for engineering practice JABEE c 1 2 2
397. 1 PR 1 1 PE ABET EC2000 83 1 1 ABETLEC2000 8 1 2 1 8 4 4 ABETEC2000 JABEE 2013a Engineering Autonomy ET R
398. 2006 Geotechnical Environmental Industrial Mining Information Bio 11 APRC 2011 2 202 2012 2 004 2013 1 971 APEC 2011 5 617 2012 6 076 2013 6 649 20183 28 IT 1 2 8 APEC 24 2012 8 1 000 APEC 5 2006 2011 2005 2 500 APEC
399. 3 CPD 4 APEC 2 2 1 2 2 3 JABEE 1 3 4 2 3 48 3 1 1 1 JABEE 2 3 CPD 8 2 2 1 2
400. E 2 135 1 E E kr b E 1
401. 1998 http 77homepage3 nifty com hideo3 docs IDE2000 pdf 2013 2006 1 82 2 http www2 iee or jp ver2 honbu 39 rinri doc 1_S2 2 pdf uk 2001 Vol 49 1 pp 2 7 2002a 2002b Vol 442 pp 47 52 2009 NEWS Vol 9 p 5 f JABEE 2002 E 10 1998 8 IDE 11 pp 36 41 2012 CPD
402. ABET EC2000 c Design a system component or process to meet desired needs JABERE 1 2 3 1 2 10 87 3 1 1
403. CPD O 1 1 1 3
404. JABEE JABEE JABEE JABEE JABEE 2 I
405. 1995 JABEE 2003 TT 1996 3 1 r 3 1 N
406. 1996 2003 10 2009 2013 8 2012 1 2014 72 250 CPD CPD 10 2014 1 500 1
407. 2009 IEA Graduate Attributes GA and Proftessional Competency Profiles 2 IEA2009 ABETLEC2000 4
408. 9 71 41 g2 m4 5 2 1 1 APEC 3 professionalization Millerson profession 6 Millerson profession 6 Millerson 1964 9 professionalization 2 1 2 b profession
409. WEB 80 211 14 260 60 7 5 7 rr H 2000 11 APEC 7 35 APEC 22 APEC 2001 Structual Civil 2 2004 Mechanical Chemical Electrical
410. 2014 97 20 Engineering 4 Engineering Education 4 B E E 2 2
411. 23 http homepage3 nifty com hideo3 docs 2012CPD pdf 2013 2 28 2011 2012 No ETE 12 37 pp 17 22 2012 1998 Vo1 46 6 pp 24 9 Ez me 2011 151 5 E 12 14 15 2000 18 10 28 IDE vol 402 1998 E 3 pp 50 5 IDRE JABEE E CPD URL LU 2000 Vol 48 1 pp 21 5
412. 1998 4 2002b fi mo mp 1989 6 8 2 AN
413. Ep te 3 1991 3
414. JABEE JABEE Rngineering Act ABET NSPE 1 1 1 1 lt 1 JABEE
415. URL http www engineer or jp c_topics 0007000706 html 2013 2 28 2005b 21 URL http www engineer orjp c_topics 0007000706 html 2013 2 28 2007 1 URL http wwwr engineer or jp c_topics 0007000029 html 2013 2 28 149 2014 Ud 2010 2011 2012 JABEE 2018a gt Ho
416. 3 4 PC 1 uk 2 3 4 5
417. 7 3 5 Fr 1991 7 3 5 rrofessional Engineer 2000 6 3 CPD
418. Cambridge Unnversity Press 1 2000 1998 1999 1 p 25 152 2000 2005 5 ET ET 2009
419. 12 2007 I 2 1999 11 19 14 1997 8 7 2002b 49 JABEE E 2007 I 2 24 E 1996 7 a 2001
420. 80 EC2000 1 4 3 ABET EC2000 1 1 8 1 ABET 2 IEA ABETEC2000 1 2 professional 1 2 1 professional 1 profession Millerson profession 6 3 profession 1 2 2 engineering profession 1 2 APEC 80 2 1 APEC 1 3
421. APEC 1996 5 3 2000 3 17 4 26 APEOC Engineer 5 1 2 3 E APEC
422. CPD 1 1 1 CPD 2012 IntPE APEC Eng PDE 1996 1999 1999 2002 PDE 2005 PDE 2007 CPD 2003 CPD 1 1 1 2012 3 CPD 15 12 PDE
423. engage in lifelong learning JABEE 7 6 1 2 1 2 3 2009ajb 2 desired needs
424. 2014a 117 5 119 5 1 2000 3 1
425. 5 2 12 GA 8 PC GA PC GA PC
426. AGA amp PC 2012 SO vl ee ee 146 1 1990 2 1 1995 11 Economic Cooperation APEC Asia Pacific M 1999 JABEE Japan Acceditation Board for Engineering Education JABEE 2000
427. CEAB Canadian Engineering Accreditation Board 1 2 5 ABET 1 2 6 JABEE CEAB ABRT 1 2 7 JABEE 1 2 8 JABEE 1 2 9 CEAB ABET 42 acl 1 2 10 5 1 2 5 CEAB Engineering desgn integrates mathematics basic sciences engineering sclences and complementary studies in developi
428. Engineer 2005 JABEE DR OT MO APEC JABERE 1 5 3 APEC 1999 6 APEC 2
429. TLEC2000 a 2000 23 b ABETLEC2000 f Understand professional and ethical responsibihty h Understand the impact of engineering solutions in a global and societal context c ABET EC2000 g Communicate effectively T ABETLEC2000 a Apply knowledge of mathem
430. atics science and engineering b Design and conduct experiments analyze andinterpret data ABETEC2000 i Recognize the need for and engage in lifelong learning k Use modern engineering tools necessary for engineering practice ABET EC2000 c Design a system component or process to meet desired needs g ABET EC2000 e Identify formulate and solve engineering problems JABEE ABETEC2000 d Function on multi disciplinary teams Have knowledge of contemporary issues JABEE ABETLEC2000 2 3 30 2
431. ce program_20130301 pdf 2013 8 2000 PED 2002 1 44 http wwwjfes or jp _pde pde01 b 021106 pdf 2013 10 https www jsee or jp action common_download_main amp upload_id 1288 2018 2004 E 1 PDE 8 E 11 Vol 16 1 pp 1 10 EAJ News No 97 http wwwr eaj or jp eajnews news97 news97 6 j html 2013 10 13 NSPE National Society of Professional Engineers 1999 Opinions of the Board of Ethical Review NSPE 2013 2 28
432. ering change 2013 10 26 I Lattuca R L Terenzimi T P Volwein F J Peterson D G 2006b The Changing Face of Engineering Education the BRIDGE NAE National Academy of Engineering Summer 2006 5 13 http www nae edu Publications Bridge ReformingEngineering Education TheChangingFaceofEngineeringRducation aspx 2013 10 26 Martin M and Schinzinger R 2000 Introduction to Engineering Ethics McGraw Hill 2006 Millerson G 1964 The Qualifying Associations A Study in Professionalization London Routledge and Kegan Paul Mitcham C 2001 The Achivement of Technology and Ethics A perspective from the United States Goujon P and Dubreuil B eds TEchnology and Ethics A European Quest tor Responsible Engineering Peeters 565 81 148 Fs RF 1979
433. h as economnc envnronmental socal pohtical ethical health and safety manufacturabilhty and sustainability Engineering design is the process of devising a system component or process to meet desired needs It is a decision making process often iterative in which the basic sclences mathematics and the engineering sclence are applied to convert resources optimally to meet these stated needs 1 2 7 2009b
434. ineering Dractice Ability to accomplish duties premeditatedly alone and in team d Function on multi disciplinary teams 3 1 2 PR ABETLEC2000 a k ABETLEC2000 2 ABETEC 2000 8 1 1 ABETEC2000 3 1 2 100 PE JABERE 1 42
435. l context i Recognize the need for and engage in lifelong learning 142 a recognition of the need for and an ability to engage in life 1ong learning j Have knowledge of contemporary issues a knowledge of contemporary issues k Use modern engineering tools necessary for engineering practice an ability to use the techniques skills and modern engineering tools necessary for engineering practice IEA Graduate Attributes and Professional Competencies ver 2 2009 IEAGA amp PC 2012 2 2009 6 18
436. m6 b 3 2004 2012 G1 G2 f G4 G5 G3 G6 2 1 1 9 occupation profession 41 2007 2007 2004 2005 2012 2004 2009a 74 2 1 1 3 E Greenwood Millerson
437. ng elements systems and processes to meet specfic needs It is a creative iterative and often open ended process subject to constraints which may be governed by standards or legislation to varying degrees depending upon the disciphne These constraints may relate to economic health _safety environmental social or other pertiment interdisctphnary factors 1 2 6 ABRBT An abihty to desngn a system component or process to meet desnred needs within reahstic constraints suc
438. on occupation profession professional 34 Professional Engineer
Download Pdf Manuals
Related Search